Is India a fascist rogue state? | Pakistan Today

Is India a fascist rogue state?

  • The RSS ideology’s triumph is a nightmare

India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi, like so many other Bharatya Janata Party stalwarts, makes no bones about having been a member of the RSS. The RSS is ubiquitous in all states and Union territories. Without its consent, no-one can get a party ticket. :

The RSS is a conglomerate of disguised terrorists. The Indian media dare not focus on its violent activities But it is sometimes exposed by viral images of violence by RSS workers. Images show the RSS participating in Delhi riots, lynching suspected beef eaters, or Muslim prayergoers. RSS militants get identified while chanting religious slogans. Gandhi’s assassin, Nathuram Godse, was an RSS member. It was the RSS which spearheaded demolition of the Babri mosque on  December 6, 1992,

The present-day advocates (pracharak) of the RSS claim that their organization is pacifist. However, an ideologue, M.S. Golwalkar, referred to Christians and Muslims as “internal threats”. He praised Nazi Germany as an example of “race pride” from which India could learn. Satish Misra, a political analyst at the Observer Research Foundation in New Delhi says, [Indian prime minister] “Modi is the most loved child of the RSS.” Neerja Chowdhury, a political commentator and columnist reported, ‘The party advocates that to be a true Indian one has to be a Hindu. It describes other religious minorities, Sikhs, Jains, Buddhists, as part of India, because their faiths originated there. They believe that even India’s Muslims are actually Hindu because their Hindu ancestors were forced to convert to Islam’.

In a statement, Arena, the Chair of the European Parliament’s human rights panel, reminded India that as a sitting member of the UN Human Rights Council, the country had pledged to “continue to foster the genuine participation and effective involvement of civil society in the promotion and protection of human rights”. “Therefore, I call on the Indian government to meet this pledge, in a manner worthy of the global role model it aspires to be. It is high time for India to translate words into action. In this context, I also wish to call on the EU to address these concerns within the EU-India Human Rights Dialogue

The anti-conversion laws in states, ban on cow slaughter, annexation of the disputed Jammu and Kashmir State, and now the combined civil code on the anvil are the RSS’s demands. The RSS wants to convert non-Hindus to Hinduism under its homecoming (ghar wapsi) policy. C.P. Bhishikar’s biography of Hedgewar, Keshav Sanghnirmata, tells how RSS founder equated Muslims to yavana (snakes). RSS spurns the Indian Constitution and believes India is a place for the Hindu nation (rashtra), to live in exclusively.

The RSS has been busy re-imaging itself in media as a `cultural, not a genocidal movement’, Sunil Ambekar, secretary of the RSS’s student wing (Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad) launched a book ‘The RSS: Roadmaps For The 21st Century’. As a prelude to the book launch, the RSS hosted an in-house closed-door briefing for foreign journalists based in India. Earlier, it held an all-India enclave in which ‘intellectuals’ from all over India, including the RSS’s puppet Muslim Munch also participated.

The RSS’s genocidal role is a caricature of Indian constitution, visualizing a `sovereign socialist secular democratic republic ‘and its Article prohibiting discrimination on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth. The Indian CDS’s outburst about overrunning nuclear Pakistan or exercising military options on China is in keeping with the Hindutva mentality. His statement caricatures the    Indian prime minister’s assurance at all-parties’ conference China did not trespass an inch of Indian territory.

The Hindu civil and military leadership is nostalgic about ancient India’s prosperity during the Maurya and the Gupta periods achieved through total-war tactics (Major General Rajendra Nath, Military Leadership in India: Vedic Period to Indo-Pak Wars). The Indian Army is wedded to a keynote of Krishna’s strategy: `The end justifies the means. The truth may often have to be sacrificed in pursuit of victory (Karma Parva)’. Brihaspati and Kautilya (Arthashastra) stress koota yuddha (no-holds-barred war) or maya yuddha (war by deception) against the non-Hindu.

A state that flouts international treaties and conventions is a rogue state. India reneged on its commitment to hold a plebiscite in illegally occupied Jammu and Kashmir State. It expresses disdain for the UN resolutions pointing out human rights violations in India. A recent case in point is India’s outrage on the international outcry at the molestation of women in India, including at Hathras (Uttar Pradesh). Not only the UN but also the European Union expressed profound sadness and concern ‘at the the continuing cases of sexual violence against women and girls in India’. Maria Arena, the Chair of the European Parliament’s Subcommittee on Human Rights, listed a litany of areas of concern in India with a reminder: “It is high time for India to translate words into action.”

In a statement, Arena, the Chair of the European Parliament’s human rights panel, reminded India that as a sitting member of the UN Human Rights Council, the country had pledged to “continue to foster the genuine participation and effective involvement of civil society in the promotion and protection of human rights”. “Therefore, I call on the Indian government to meet this pledge, in a manner worthy of the global role model it aspires to be. It is high time for India to translate words into action. In this context, I also wish to call on the EU to address these concerns within the EU-India Human Rights Dialogue.”

Pointing out that the rule of law is the very cornerstone of the EU’s relationship with India, Arena referred to the Amnesty International India report on human rights violations committed by Delhi police during the riots in the capital in February. “Marginalised communities, religious minorities, particularly Muslims, a vocal and vibrant civil society and critics of government policies have been under increasing pressure for a long time. Widespread protests over the proposed citizenship verification process and the discriminatory citizenship law amendments have resulted in arbitrary detentions and an unnecessary loss of life. Journalists and other peaceful critics continue to be arrested under draconian counter-terrorism and sedition laws, while human rights defenders are unceasingly and severely targeted by the authorities,” Arena noted.

She also expressed concern over Amnesty International India being forced to halt its work in the country “due to government reprisals”.

In a background note circulated along with the statement, it was pointed out that the 2004 EU-India Strategic Partnership is based on shared values of democracy, the rule of law and respect for human rights. Further, it was pointed out that both countries had endorsed the “EU-India Strategic Partnership: A Roadmap to 2025” during the 5th European Union-India Summit on July 15, reaffirming commitment to promoting the shared values of human rights and fundamental freedoms.

Earlier in January, six different political groupings in the European Parliament moved separate resolutions against the Citizenship Amendment Act. Together, the resolutions had the backing of 626 members of the 751-member European Parliament. Indian diplomats had to work overtime to defer the vote to March, by which time the pandemic bailed India out of the tight spot.

The writer is a freelance journalist, has served in the Pakistan government for 39 years and holds degrees in economics, business administration, and law. He can be reached at [email protected]



2 Comments

  1. Sunbig2 said:

    A country which is not secular and BY LAW discriminates against its minorities talks about RSS. RSS supports secularism and equality of all religions before law. Pakistan and its government are hypocrites. Im the dim thinks the world does not see his hypocrisy. In the UN, he does not talk about human rights but Islamophobia, he does not talk about humans but muslims and muslims get angry when freedom of expression is misused and this is a country whose citizens illegally migrate and are provided refuge carry out terror attacks on innocent civilians in the host countries. The parents and friends of this terror perpetrator say they are proud of what he did. The terror perpetrator is himself just 18 years old. And yet Pakistanis think why the world thinks negatively of them. Silly nincompoomp paki:::s

  2. Giri said:

    Look Ma…who is talking secularism, liberal democracy, and all that crap. A Pakistani Muslim. Who else? Do you see the irony here? Do you see the hypocrisy here? If not then you are Muslim too. LOL!

Comments are closed.

Top