A ban on the sale of cattle for slaughter in India’s richest state is threatening to push millions of farmers into penury, deepening distress in the countryside and fanning resentment against Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ruling party.
Slaughter of cows, considered sacred in Hinduism, has historically been banned in most states but was rarely enforced in India, the world’s largest exporter of beef.
But over the past year, states ruled by Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), such as Maharashtra, have broadened the ban to include other types of cattle, like bulls and bullocks, and Hindu vigilantes have stepped up attacks on traders to enforce the prohibition.
The stricter rules come as Modi and the nationalist BJP laid greater stress on India’s Hindu faith, to which the majority of the population belongs.
Minority groups, including around 180 million Muslims, have expressed concern over the implications.
The impact of the beef ban has been significant.
Prices of cattle have fallen across the country, India’s meat exports fell 13 per cent in the April-December period and rival beef supplier Brazil is gaining from India’s loss.
Read more: Beef row: 2 Muslims cattle traders hanged to death in India
It has also left millions of farmers, already reeling from bad harvests due to back-to-back droughts and unseasonal rains, struggling to sell animals they can no longer feed or water.
“I wonder what the government wants – our survival or the cattle’s?” said farmer Revaji Choudhary, standing next to a pair of bulls he has been trying to sell for weeks in a cattle market in Maharashtra.
Traditionally, farmers have sold cattle in a drought year to butchers, mostly Muslims, and bought new ones when their earnings rise after monsoon showers.
That cycle has been broken and could leave farmers with little money to buy seeds or fertiliser ahead of the next sowing season, starting in June.
Farmer suicides have nearly doubled in the drought-hit Marathwada region of Maharashtra.
To ban or not to ban?
Their predicament is causing concern within the BJP, which has been trying to bolster its credentials in the countryside, where most of India’s 1.3 billion people live.
Rural distress contributed to an embarrassing defeat for the party last year in a state election, and more state polls are due over the coming year.
In the federal budget last month, Modi’s government pledged nearly $13 billion on rural development, aiming to double farmer’s incomes by 2022.
Maharashtra BJP legislator Bhimrao Dhonde said the government’s priority should be to support farmers, and they should be allowed to sell their cattle to whomever they want. “It is time to withdraw the ban,” Dhonde told reporters.
Madhu Chavan, a spokesman for the BJP in Maharashtra, said Dhonde’s view did not reflect that of the party. “The party thinks the ban is necessary,” he said, adding that more money would be made available to alleviate the effects of drought if needed.
Millions of cows
Maharashtra, home to India’s financial hub Mumbai, has been particularly badly hit by drought.
In one district the government imposed rules that prevent assembly of more than five people around a water tanker or borewell to prevent riots.
Cows and buffalos need 70 litres of water per day.
Many farmers are simply abandoning their cattle.
The state has opened hundreds of temporary shelters to house around 250,000 heads of cattle until their owners are ready to take them back, but experts say at least another 4 million animals need to be looked after in Maharashtra.
Hindu groups such as the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) that had promised to build shelters said they, too, were short on cash and the government should do more.
Laxmi Narayan Chandak, head of the Maharashtra unit of VHP’s cow protection committee, said his organisation has been able to start only one facility that holds 150 cattle. “Nearly 700,000 cows and bulls … will starve to death or will be smuggled to slaughter houses. We have to save them,” said Chandak.
He added that only pure Indian breeds “that are worthy of worship” should be sheltered.
Also read: Indian police arrest Muslim students in Rajasthan over beef rumours
Every Monday, hundreds of farmers like Choudhary travel to a weekly cattle market in Belhe village, around 200 km (124 miles) east of Mumbai, but with so few people buying, it is more in hope than expectation.
Cattle prices in the state have fallen 40 per cent to 60 per cent.
Choudhary, who earns around 200,000 Indian rupees ($3,000) in a good monsoon year, said he has incurred losses as his crops wilted due to drought.
He paid 40,000 rupees for his pair of bulls a year ago and is willing to sell them for 20,000 rupees now. He still cannot find a buyer. “We are forced to depend on tankers for drinking water. How can we supply water to cattle?” Choudhary asked.
