‘Time for talks is over’, COAS Sharif’s message to PM Sharif: report

17
171

ISLAMABAD-

 

At Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s palatial offices in Islamabad this week, the army chief sat down to deliver the head of government a message he did not want to hear: The time for talks with the troublesome Pakistani Taliban was over.

 

Sharif came to power a year ago promising to find a peaceful settlement with the Islamist militant group, but as round after round of talks failed, the powerful armed forces favoured a military solution.

 

Their patience finally ran out and, late on Tuesday afternoon, during a tense meeting, the army effectively declared it would override a crucial plank of the government’s strategy and take matters into its own hands.

 

“The army chief and other military officers in the room were clear on the military’s policy: the last man, the last bullet,” a government insider with first-hand knowledge of the meeting told a foreign news agency.

 

Asked to sum up the message General Raheel Sharif wanted to convey at the gathering, he added: “The time for talk is over.”

 

The next day, Pakistani forces launched rare air strikes against militants holed up in the remote, lawless tribal belt near the Afghan border. It is not clear whether Sharif authorized the operation.

 

On Thursday, they backed that up with the first major ground offensive against the Taliban there, undermining Sharif’s year-long attempt to end a bloody insurgency across his country through peaceful means.

 

Disagreement over the militant threat is the latest row to flare up between the government and military, and relations between the two branches of power are at their lowest ebb for years, according to government officials.

 

The government did say talks with the Taliban would go on.

 

“We will talk with those who are ready for it and the (military) operation is being launched against those who are not ready to come to the negotiating table,” spokesman Pervez Rashid told local media on Thursday.

 

But the operations put the military, which has a long record of intervening in civilian rule through plots and coups, firmly back at the centre of Pakistan’s security policy.

 

The balance of power is shifting at a time when foreign troops are preparing to withdraw from Afghanistan, and arch-rival India has just elected a Hindu nationalist leader promising to be more assertive on the international stage.

 

“This is the clearest signal yet that the army will dictate its terms now,” a member of Sharif’s cabinet said.

 

TALIBAN ON THE OFFENSIVE

 

The Pakistani Taliban, as distinct from the Afghan Taliban which is actively targeting NATO forces in Afghanistan, is believed to be behind attacks on Pakistani soldiers and civilians that have killed thousands in recent years.

 

The Pakistan army has distinguished between “good” Taliban like the feared Haqqani network – who do not attack Pakistani security forces but fight in Afghanistan – and “bad” Taliban, indigenous Pakistani militants who are seeking to create an Islamic state.

 

While Pakistan’s military wants to go after the “bad” Taliban, it has, despite pressure from Washington, largely avoided taking on groups who launch attacks against coalition forces in Afghanistan from Pakistan’s North Waziristan region.

 

Prompting the latest intervention, the Pakistani Taliban have become increasingly bold, striking the army in tribal areas including a recent battle in which an army major died. Earlier this month, nine soldiers were killed in an explosion near the Afghan border.

 

“We will avenge the blood of every last soldier. Talks or no talks, the army will retaliate,” said one military official, who, like most others interviewed for this article, spoke on condition of anonymity due to the sensitivity of the subject.

 

The army has ruled Pakistan for more than half of its history. Sharif himself was toppled by the army in 1999 during his previous tenure as prime minister.

 

But, humiliated after a secret 2011 U.S. raid that killed Osama bin Laden on Pakistani soil, the army stood back from politics and supported last year’s first democratic transition of power which brought Sharif back to office.

 

Sharif manoeuvred carefully, hand picking a new army chief and trying to forge a partnership with the military in the early days of his tenure, but the overtures had little lasting impact.

 

TRADE, DIPLOMACY

 

There are other signs of civil-military discord.

 

Sharif came to power promising to rebuild relations with India, but has been under pressure to toughen his stance from hardliners at home, particularly within the army.

 

The nuclear-armed neighbours have fought three wars since independence from Britain in 1947, two of them over the still-disputed Himalayan territory of Kashmir.

 

Sharif’s policies towards India have been heavily scrutinized; some in the army justify its hefty budget by pointing to – and, critics say, playing up – the potential threat from India.

 

And despite signs the military has become more amenable to overtures from its old foe than in the past, a trade deal pushed by the prime minister and aimed at improving ties with India was cancelled at the last minute after pressure from the army, top government officials said.

 

Sharif now faces a dilemma over whether to accept an invitation by Indian Prime Minister-designate Narendra Modi to attend his inauguration next week.

 

The army is also bitter about the trial of former military ruler Pervez Musharraf, who ousted Sharif from power in 1999 and was arrested after he returned to Pakistan to take part in last year’s election.

 

Ties with Afghanistan have never been easy, but some officials believe the army wants to torpedo the government’s relationship with a future Kabul administration, risking deterioration in regional security as NATO troops prepare to leave this year.

 

Generals have jealously guarded the right to dictate policy on Afghanistan, seeing friendly guerrilla groups as “assets” to blunt the influence of India there.

 

TENSIONS COME TO SURFACE

 

Though simmering under the surface, tensions between the government and the army spilled into the open last month when a popular journalist was shot by unknown gunmen, and his channel, Geo News, blamed the army’s powerful spy agency, the Directorate of Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI).

 

Public criticism of the shadowy ISI is almost unheard of in Pakistan. In a rare public response, the army demanded that Geo News, the country’s most-watched news channel, be shut down.

 

The government’s media regulator has since resisted the army’s demands to cancel the channel’s license, which the military sees as a direct sign of defiance.

 

“Everyone was looking out to see how the government would treat the army in this crisis — as a friend or foe?” said a senior military official. “But the government allowed this to become a free-for-all, army-hunting season.”

 

For Sharif, buckling under military pressure is a major risk. “This is not about one TV channel but about freedom of expression and about living in a democracy,” Rashid said. “We should live and let live.”

 

But despite putting on a brave front, officials say the government is feeling under siege.

 

“Never in the last year has the government felt weaker or more vulnerable,” one of Sharif’s key economic advisers said. “Now every time we have to take a major decision, on India, on Afghanistan, we will have to think ‘How will the army react?'”

 

A serving general said the army chief would always pick the “institution over the constitution if push comes to shove,” adding: “As a society and a state, we have to avoid a context in which the army is pushed to do something it doesn’t want to.”

17 COMMENTS

  1. This write up is based on lot of speculation and un-named sources. The obvious source of tension is retired army officers who lost power and they have not digested the reality. This group is led by Mush and him taking refuge in army hospital forcing current army leadership to get involved in the issue. Media has its own problems. The market is not big enough to sustain eighty channels. It is battle for survival by any means possible. Eventually, breaking rules and laws does nobody any good.

  2. Very well written article, though it is not completely based on ground facts yet it depicts the reality to a fair extend.

  3. Can any legitimate government in the world with million strong military tolerate the killing of innocent citizen by the Armed criminal religious extremist (Talibaan) .. Why would some unlawful persons carry a gun, kill and terrorized public. Pakistan Army decision going after the these murderer is very justifiable.

  4. NS is a weak government, unable to take key decisions on many crucial issues I.e Geo, polio & Karachi & appointment of key position to run many department . Overall NS running government as Itefaq foundries

  5. Pakistan faces serious challenges.Nawaz govt is incompetent came through fake elections.Common Pakistanis don’t want such democracy.Popular public demand is peace & accountability of present & past corrupt rulers.People don’t trust judiciary also.Pakistanis want to live with peace & honour.

  6. Where is democracy..its a one family rule of brothers daughters nephews sons in law and samadhis…cronyism at its worst in the name of democracy…Parliament a rubber stamp visited six times in one year by PM while Senate still waits to see him…Development only restricted to Lahore and metro projects inflated in costs by at least 50 % NO transparency in contracts all in name of Pak China Friendship Coal Power is scam of century dwarfing Raj a Rentals and Mr 10 %.. Coal per projects are inflated by 50 percent by makers of Guinnee records so the amount of coal power corruption is 4 billion dollars ON a phone call from Beijing NEPRA announces new tarriff of 27 %return Highest in whole world .People in MOfussil hinterand continue to toil on broken katcha roads while Lahoris enjoy metro rides Schools hospitals in tatters People die of Polio and soldiers asked to buy vaccine..This is a sham of democracy run by shameless family…never ready to learn from history unless punched in face..They r spending billions on media campaigns to create an illusion which masks their legendary corruption..

  7. nawaz family whenever they come in power they forget their past and donot learn. in their past rule by their such like shameless acts and wrong policies their govt was toppled down and sorry to say they did not learn from history . latoon kay bhoot batoon say nhee mantay and na hi kutty ko ghee hazam hota hai . they dont deserve respect. juma juma 4 din howay hai geo ko ayay howay and yah isi and army say ziada mulk ka hamdard bana phirta hai who takes aid fron raw and mosad . foreign puppit. and jin bhaee sahab nay oper comment diya hai kay yah retd army officer ki man gharat stories hain to my dear retd army officers was not retaliating after this meeting on sunday but active military took the action against taliban. hope i m clear.. app to asay likh rahay hain jasay yah sara kuch app kay ghar kay drawing room mai bhait kay app ki eyes kay samnay hoa hai . hope i m clear. NS govt plays like kids and when gets hit then runs away to saudi lap and starts weeping but this time they wont be escaped by saudies.INSHAHLLAH

    • Your point is very eloquentry hammered home Javed Shb. Thanks for the candor and every honest and pragmatic Pakistani will voice the same.

  8. Democracy is nothing but to create problems by western white elephants for the underdeveloped countries like Pakistan. China has managed to protect itself from this so called democracy. In Pakistan, we need an honest and cruel dictator unlike the previous so called dictators, who could kill Zardari, Nawaz shareef, Imran khan, the ezedi mullas, all of these hypocrats with their entire families. People of Pakistan are waiting for such change.
    A true Pakistani.

  9. sure there is something going on and his old habit of flirting with stupidity remains there…..army is better option for Pakistan as there is no democracy with this so called junkies and if you aren't convinced with me then bring some new one on the block as we sick and dying of these rotten faces

  10. Nawaz Sharif is in trouble. This means Musharraf also is a soldier so mess with him and hang him, Nawaz buddy you are gone. Sorry Mr Kiyani you made a wrong case selection and also Nawaz you are gone at their hands. Make your khair as Kakkar chucked you out, Karamat and Asif Ali Nawaz you got ticked but they were calm, Musharraf sacked you and now Raheel will eat you. Good bye to good riddance and castration of the map of this world the Sharifs.

  11. In fact this article is totally a biased article against Pak Army and it does not carry any valuable information in it. the writer is so stupid and appears to be a brainless, senseless inhuman who never cares for how many innocent people been killed so far and how many more will be if these animals won't be stopped.
    As long as democracy is concerned, its not the true form of govt. and these looters so called elected rulers do not have any ineterst or respect for the country, it's people. They just want to loot this unfortunate country, which was created after so many sacrifices to let the people live peacefully, prosper and practice according to their beliefs.
    Javed Sb and Rabia very well said. I totally agree to you and am sure every sensible Pakistani would understand and would never ever support anything against Pakistan, Pakistani people and Pak Army.

Comments are closed.