Too many people have too much to lose – and that includes the current military top brass
Generals in Pakistan are generally quite lovely creatures, short, stout and often carrying a moustache as proof of masculinity, they are rather outstanding specimens of humanity. Medals adorned on their chests and up to four-stars protruding on their shoulder straps, they are driven by a genuine concern for the suffering of humanity around them. And thus this is why they meddle in matters unrelated to them. And humanity around them agrees, for the most part.
What else explains the fact that of the five military dictators to have taken over the reins of the country, four died without a stain on their sparkling military shirts. Generals in Pakistan live well and die well, unless they get on the wrong side of one of their own proxies, but generally speaking, it is a good life. A solid clique in both media and civil society begin to debate “whether there will be a military coup?” every two months as if it was a right somehow being wrongfully denied to our country’s best golf players and property dealers. Another statement that is considered to have credence is that a military dictator in Pakistan either “resigns, goes into self-exile or is killed”. Having survived death, Musharraf had resigned and gone into self-exile and taken up residence in London, where he had been cashing in on selling out to the United States with a choice series of paid lectures on the subject Americans love most: the war on terror in Pakistan.
Perhaps this is why the former General – and usurper President – Pervez Musharraf decided to return to the country to try out what it was to be a bloody civilian. The lock up was the least of what he expected. It has not turned out to be a pretty sight – and in many ways, gladly so. When the first set of bails of the former general – although perhaps Mush is the first general to fall outside the “once a general, always a general” metaphor so popular amongst military ranks – was granted, it appeared that the “deal struck in the Holy Kingdom” would go uncontested by the elites of Pakistan. Arguably, the former general is now off the golf course, and learning how to live the life enjoyed by one of us “bloody civilians”. Of course, with him locked up in his own farmhouse, it is still a far cry from the squatter that the average citizen inhabits.
The “Musharraf law,” i.e., being picked up and declared ‘missing’, has not been applied, and he should be thankful. There are many in the country that want the former general dead, although that would be the most boring of ends for him. A full trial in each of the cases against him is required – including, most importantly, a trial for treason, which is the one on which there is a lack of political consensus. The former Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani once said, “I have no love lost for Musharraf. If the parliament decides to try him, I will be with the parliament. Article 6 cannot be applied to one individual, those who supported him are today in my cabinet and some of them have also joined the PML-N. The MMA, the MQM and the PML-Q supported him. This is why I have said that it is not doable.” One can add, former Musharraf supporters have also joined the ‘harbinger of change’, the PTI. This suggests that while the caretaker setup has declared that it does not have the mandate to try Musharraf for treason, and the Senate has passed a resolution calling for such a trial, once the next National Assembly is in, a political consensus to try him still appears to be unlikely.
While insiders say that Musharraf has been abandoned with an understanding that accountability will remain limited, a military coup in 2014 has not been ruled out. The question is: why is a coup even an option? Military men are no more than security guards employed by civilians for their protection. The reversal of this ordering is unacceptable at any point. Moreover, how come one former general becomes the face of public accountability, without questioning the entire institutional ethos? If it is true – although there are reasons to doubt it – that the military ethos involves only top-down obedience, independent of any other considerations, then the military ethos needs to be changed. Making Musharraf accountable for an institutional problem would serve no great purpose.
How former generals look at civilian courts should be a good indicator of the problem at hand. The first thing they attempt is to avoid the indemnity of showing up before a civil judge. For this purpose, they either attempt to pursue a trial through military courts, using the refrain of the Army Act 1952, that arguably excludes military officials from the realm of common [colonial] law. This was successfully adopted by former Generals Khalid Zaheer, Khalid Munir and Afzal Muzaffar when charges were proven against them in the National Logistics Cell scandal – the three were re-inducted into the army and got away with the slap on the back (of the “well done” variety) of a court martial. If this does not work, they attempt to degrade the court, the judges and the process of law. This was successfully adopted by the former Generals Aslam Beg and Asad Durrani when appearing before the Supreme Court to explain their position with respect to doling out money to politicians – and as it stands both appear to have got away with it. So as a former General and COAS, Pervez Musharraf could not be blamed for fleeing arrest from the Islamabad High Court, a court that he purportedly himself set up to undermine the Supreme Court back in his heydays.
That Musharraf made the choice of being the first military dictator in Pakistan’s history to attempt a return to the country was based on the same trust: a general, serving or retired, cannot be tried in Pakistan. With his bail in the Benazir Bhutto murder trial newly cancelled, and his disqualification from contesting election, it is hoped that at least his multiple trials shall all take place. But as some ex-Generals, namely Jamshed Ayaz and Aslam Beg, chose to remind us on Tuesday, that they, and others in their clique, are not happy with the possible ‘humiliation’ of Musharraf. With at least nine of the serving corps commanders promoted during the decade long Musharraf regime, there is certainly both loyalty and complicity amongst the military top brass. Former COAS Aslam Baig has been more threatening, but those come from a man with clipped wings. Perhaps, there is now little need to be worried about what he says, and the question of military accountability needs to be asked with seriousness.
There is a need to answer the question, rather than leaving it hanging.
The writer is the general secretary (Lahore) of the Awami Workers Party. He is a journalist and a researcher. Contact: [email protected]
his article shows his lack of knowledge about pakistan army and its officers
they never ever discriminate the civilian as many of my family members are in army, so i know them more than u
Pakistan Today its highly disgusting
This is how the common man (bloody civilian) feels about the state of affairs. One cannot know about Pakistan if "many" of your family members are in army.
No wonder why Pakistan has gone down the drain. After 66 years, it is still a failed country.
surprise surprise, an indian comments on something that has nothing to do with him. shocking!
Indians are keenly watching, all the wrong things going on with the innocent civilians, of our donated land.
and about musharraf;
During General Pervez Musharraf’s regime, the Human Development Index rose 18.9 per cent — an annual average of 2.7 per cent.
From 2007 to 2012 it only went up by 3.4 per cent, just under 0.7 per cent per annum.
Pakistan’s expenditure on social sectors is lower than some of the poorest African countries such as the Democratic Republic of Congo, which spends 1.2% of GDP on health and 6.2% on education, versus Pakistan’s 0.8% on health and 1.8% on education.
UNITED NATIONS report 🙂
Following which the country crashed because policies of countries dont base on regimes, they are meant to build the country on with or without the dictator.
We're still suffering from the US alliance. Step on US soil and you will find out how people think of a Pakistani.
Haris Shaukat and Ehsan Ali Naqvi, please abstain from using abusive language. This is a public forum and all participants are expected to voice their opinions in a decent manner. Your cooperation will be much appreciated.
God bless the writer. A beautiful and brave writing on the political/ military life of Paistan. It is ultimately the poor people, who are suffering in such a condition in developing countries. I wish the writer a long healthy life and bright future.
Brilliant write-up!
Very bold! Very well written.
you cant compare yourself with a army man. you cant live life like a army man. how risky their lives,they devote whole life to defend you and at the end you saying we are same no way…if Army is alive then Pakistan exits . writing these type of thing are very easy rather than face the enemy on border..
If the given name is The Supreme Court of Pakistan, it must be supreme over all other courts military or civil. Period.
his article shows his lack of knowledge about pakistan army and its officers
they never ever discriminate the civilian as many of my family members are in army, so i know them more than u
Pakistan Today its highly disgusting
and about musharraf;
During General Pervez Musharraf’s regime, the Human Development Index rose 18.9 per cent — an annual average of 2.7 per cent.
From 2007 to 2012 it only went up by 3.4 per cent, just under 0.7 per cent per annum.
Pakistan’s expenditure on social sectors is lower than some of the poorest African countries such as the Democratic Republic of Congo, which spends 1.2% of GDP on health and 6.2% on education, versus Pakistan’s 0.8% on health and 1.8% on education.
UNITED NATIONS report 🙂
bullshit indian agent
u r bullshit!
Haris Shaukat and Ehsan Ali Naqvi, please abstain from using abusive language. This is a public forum and all participants are expected to voice their opinions in a decent manner. Your cooperation will be much appreciated.
I have a very bad feeling that the cases against Musharraf will not stop him from political manipulation on behalf of the establishment. His old supporters are still active in politics and Musharraf can gain plenty of favors from the upcoming government. Not to mention the tables turning against him will close plenty of options for the military to meddle with politics.
Dear Editor. You have never published my unbiased opinion/ comments? Are you scared??
Justice is not as a justice in Pakistan same as against Musharraf ,He devoted him self 60 years of his life but his case treated as a tereriest ,how we accepte these charge againt him ,the justice of pakistan has already been 20,000 dengerious tereriest safely Release by the justice in nearly feature ,Their is big Game to support the Nawaz Shareef and to sullect as a wazeer e azam and to choose to choudry Iftikhar as a Presedent .
"Military men are no more than security guards employed by civilians for their protection."
Simple, isn't it? And yet not one in the military MAFIA understands it (intentionally)!!!
BTW: Nice bold piece! Holds less punches that the earlier "I shall not criticise the military" which was too subtle! NO NEED FOR THAT!!!!!
Let me take this opportunity to link two recent articles from the NYTimes that throw a lot of light on 1) Drones, and 2) The aiders and abetters of Raymond Davis:
A Secret Deal on Drones, Sealed in Blood
How a Single Spy [Raymond Davis] Helped Turn Pakistan Against the United States
Truth: Something Pakistan army is incapable of telling…EVER!
so let's prosecute someone who did us over once, but let's turn a blind eye to the those are now planning to do you over a fourth time?
separately, your irritating, sycophantic, pre pubescent, pseudo-sarcastic way of writing just looks desperate.
" Military men are no more than security guards employed by civilians for their protection."
military and parliament are both meant to work for the welfare of the nation in their own individual roles
the military is supposed to guard the state, not civilians per se,
its loyalties are with the state and it does not keep quite when a wannabe ameerul momineen tries fingering its established order
you must question what made Nawaz Sharif over do merit and seniority while appointing Musharraf COAS,
but of course, bashing the army would garner much more accolades nowadays
complete rubbish..military men are not hired security guards..they are from amongst us who give up a normal life to lead a tough life full of risks and put their life in danger for our country. It is easy to talk about generals but do u even know what it takes to get to that position? Pakistan exists today just because of our army and we are proud of it. You only highlight the negativity of Musharraf's tenure giving a biased opinion and not just maligning Musharraf but the whole Pakistan Army which is our pride. You talk abt missing persons.. why dont you talk abt the thousands of people killed in the last 5 years, the corruption the poor man the insecurity the instability the economic disaster. Shame on you writer rather than writing negative things abt musharraf do the same for the democratic government we enjoyed in the last 5 years. Look at where we stand right now and kindly improve your knowledge before writing articles and atleast be patriotic like the army men who are the most patriotic beings in our country.
Musharraf a former dictator is now in courts; he did heinous crimes against humanity. Now if a civilian Prime Minister can be presented in court of law and sentenced to death then why not a military general who killed hundreds of people and sold Pakistani citizens to foreign countries; a crime he had admitted himself in his book. This is now a test for the judiciary how they deal with this case. They sentenced to death a prime minister 34 years before.
THis is also a test whether Law in Pakistan is equal for every one??
Utter Rubbish
I REQUEST THE READERS TO HAVE SOME GOOD KNOWLEDGE BASED ON FACTS BEFORE COMMENTING ON SOME ISSUE. POOR OR FALSE INFORMATION CAN LEAD TO DRAW WRONG ANALYSIS WHICH IS OBVIOUS IN THIS ARTICLE. I ALSO REQUEST FROM THE ADM OF THIS WEB TO DISPLAY COMMENTS WHICH HAVE SOME SENSE AT LEAST.
my comments are never uploaded because editors want to hide truth.
Thanks for the information you have provided. In present days, the demand for real estate properties has increased in Hyderabad and it is the best place for the investors to invest in real estate.
Property Dealers in Hyderabad
Comments are closed.